Thanksgiving

Orders for Thanksgiving 2024 are now closed. We are sorry if we have missed each other this year, but because we bake everything fresh, from scratch, and without preservatives, we cannot accept additional whole pie (or high-quantity slice) orders this close to the big day.

If you have previously placed your order, you can pick it up on your selected date from our Chelsea storefront (location here). If you are picking up on Thanksgiving Day, please note that we are closing early and our pickup window is 8am to 11am that day.

We recommend refrigerating your desserts until a few hours prior to serving (or in the case of our chocolate cream pie and cheesecake, until just prior to serving).

We wish you a wonderful Thanksgiving feast and celebration!

Apple Pie

The classic. Chock-full of locally grown Gala and Pink Lady apples, gently spiced and enveloped in our double pastry crust.

Pumpkin Pie

The Thanksgiving. A delicate custard pie bursting with squash and sweet potato flavor. The perfect end to a traditional harvest meal.

Blueberry Crumb Pie

The fan favorite. Wild Maine blueberries baked in our pastry shell and topped with buttery streusel crumbs. A burst of summery flavor magically transported to fall.

Pecan Pie

The hedonist. Toasted pecans top a gently baked maple custard with just the right level of sweetness, all in our flaky pastry shell.

Chocolate Cream Pie

The chocoholic. Mounds of airy whipped cream hide a silky dark chocolate filling, which in turn gives way to the toasty cocoa of our chocolate crumb crust. Satisfyingly rich.

Cheesecake

The decadent choice. Creamy, tart, and amazingly smooth, with a burst of caramelly sweetness from the graham cracker crust.

Carrot Cake

The iconoclast. Who likes pie anyway? This moist, beautifully spiced carrot cake layered with cream cheese icing is as much a holiday celebration as any pie.